The relevant rules for deciding this CFJ are 208 and 955(b):
Rule 208/5 (Power=3)
Resolving Agoran decisions
The vote collector for an unresolved Agoran decision may resolve
it by announcement, indicating the option selected by Agora. E
SHALL do so as soon as possible after the end of the voting
period. To be valid, this announcement must satisfy the
following conditions:
(a) It is published after the voting period has ended.
(b) It clearly identifies the matter to be resolved.
(c) It specifies which option was selected by Agora, as
described elsewhere, and provides a tally of the voters'
valid ballots on the various options.
Each Agoran decision has exactly one vote collector.
This rule takes precedence over any rule that would provide
another mechanism by which an Agoran decision may be resolved.
Rule 955/11 (Power=3)
Determining the Will of Agora
(b) If the decision is whether to adopt a proposal, then the
voting index is the ratio of the strength of FOR to the
strength of AGAINST. If the voting index is greater than 1,
and greater than or equal to the decision's adoption index,
then the outcome is ADOPTED; otherwise, the outcome is
REJECTED.
R208 takes precedence over R955. R955(b) sets the outcome of the
vote on a proposal; R208 sets the condition for resolution of the
proposal. H. Assessor Murphy properly reported the votes on Prop.
5373, but inadvertently omitted the specification of the outcome as
required by R208 item (c). I therefore (draft)judge FALSE.
-----
Benjamin Schultz KE3OM
OscarMeyr
