Sherlock wrote: > > 4943 | Reward and Punishment | Goethe | 3 | 20Apr07 | D > AGAINST -- punishing recusal is fine, punishing being overturned is not.
No worries, but punishment for being overturned is already in the rule, not added by me, so you should prefer the new version by your logic. "Punishment" for being overturned is meant to counteract the reward for judging, so net gain for judging and being overturned = 0. -Goethe
