I CFJ: "Rule 2713 imposes a requirement for the Numerator to grant players their scored numbers in a timely fashion"

Arguments:

This is just standard quibbling over vocabulary. This is the only instance in the rules where "timely manner" is used instead of "timely fashion" -- is there a difference?

On the one hand, the phrases in their natural definitions are synonymous. On the one hand, "in a timely fashion" is defined by 1023 in quotes, implying exactness of wording.

Evidence:

Rule 2713/1 (Power=1.0)
Scoring Numbers

      ...

      Whenever a player scores a number as described in this rule, the
      Numerator CAN once, and SHALL in a timely manner, grant that
      player (and, if the number was scored due to the adoption of a
      proposal, also a randomly chosen other player who voted FOR on a
      referendum to adopt that proposal) a number card for each digit in
      that number, whose type is that digit.

      ...

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Rule 1023/43 (Power=2)
Agoran Time

      The following terms are defined:

      1. The phrase "in a timely fashion" means "within 7 days". This
         time period is set when the requirement is created (i.e. X days
         before the limit ends). A requirement to perform an action at
         an exact instant (e.g. "when X, Y SHALL Z"), but not "in the
         same message", is instead interpreted as a requirement to
         perform that action in a timely fashion after that instant. ...

--
Trigon

Popular Polygon and Treasuror Extraordinaire

Reply via email to