On 10/13/25 2:32 AM, Katherina Walshe-Grey via agora-official wrote:
ais523 wrote:
I call for judgement on the statement "A player who has obtained
Agoran consent to do so CAN award a badge that does not yet exist to
three or more persons simultaneously, using the mechanism in rule
2415".
This is CFJ 4124. I assign it to Trigon.
Original CFJ and caller's arguments:
https://mailman.agoranomic.org/cgi-bin/mailman/private/agora-business/2025-October/054663.html
~qenya
I judge TRUE. The text of Rule 2415 is slightly ambiguous; however, in
this case, the most reasonable reading is that awarding all of the
patent titles constitutes a single action. The parallel use of the word
"simultaneously" in Rule 2415 and Rule 478 is a confounding element, but
ultimately not strong enough of a connection to compromise the other,
more sensible, reading. There is also no current rule text or precedent
readily available limiting the number of patent titles that can be
awarded in a single action.
--
Trigon
Popular Polygon and Treasuror Extraordinaire
