Fraser,

Thanks for these editorial  clarifications; they seem like good things to do!

    This text does not imply that that other bits, including
    keyEncipherment/keyAgreement, MUST NOT be set.  I would suggest
    appending "and no other bits set", i.e.:

       In order to request signing only S/MIME certificate, the CSR MUST
       include the key usage extension with digitalSignature and/or
       nonRepudiation bits set, and no other bits set.

    Similarly for the subsequent paragraph (which can be solved the same
    way):

       In order to request encryption only S/MIME certificate, the CSR MUST
       include the key usage extension with keyEncipherment and/or
       keyAgreement bits set.


_______________________________________________
Acme mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/acme

Reply via email to