I read it and posted comments. I think we should adopt the document as a starting point.
Russ > On Aug 13, 2020, at 11:27 AM, Salz, Rich <[email protected]> > wrote: > > At IETF 108, we discussed > https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-sipos-acme-dtnnodeid/ > <https://datatracker.ietf.org/doc/draft-sipos-acme-dtnnodeid/> The minutes > of that discussion are below (thanks again Yaron) > > Should we adopt this document? At the meeting there was mild interest to do > so. > Please reply by end of next week. > > > Brian Sipos on DTN (delay-tolerant networking) Draft > > Roman: are DTN nodes on the public Internet? Or closed network? > Brian: no need for ACME if on a closed network. CA probably integrated in DTN. > Sites have gateway nodes into the open Internet. Connecting to a public (not > necessarily commercial) CA. Rick (DTN chair): are you offering to publish in > ACME as an Experimental doc, or keep it within DTN? Brian: intend to keep in > DTN. Use of URI validation is new to ACME. Rick: ACME is possibly a good way > to > resolve existing IESG discusses. Can take it off-line. Roman: would ACME > servers have understanding of DTN identifiers? Brian: they would need to be > DTN > nodes. Just like the ACME server that implements the SMTP validation draft. > Use > case is inter-site DTN. Node is accepting bundles from other domains, lower > trust exists. Yoav: ACME servers are CAs. They are reluctant to provide > service > to anything other than the normal web use case. Brian: no expectation of > uptake > in generic ACME servers. Rich: precedent for non-web use cases [missed > specifics]. Rick: DTN is a small focused WG, not sure they have the bandwidth > to take it on. Would be happy if ACME does. Brian: and this is so similar to > SMTP. YN: hum? Roman: ask re: familiarity. YN: we know the answer. Hum: have > you read it? pianissimo. YN: will not ask on adoption. Alexey: ask who is > willing to review. Chat: Melinda, Russ, Rich, Alexey, Yoav. YN: let's read, > then maybe have a call for adoption. >
_______________________________________________ Acme mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/acme
