On Sep 30, 2011, at 13:59, erik quanstrom <quans...@labs.coraid.com> wrote:

> backup:
> 1.  power down mac.  remove hard drive.
> 2.  stuff drive as one gigantic file into venti.
> 
> restore:
> 1.  copy your backup onto drive
> 2.  install hard drive.  power up mac.

In principal, that's roughly what vbackup does, except with file systems 
instead of whole disks and without taking things apart. I decided I didn't need 
to store each version of the OS files; if you want whole images, look at 
vbackup (or, yes, time machine).

I don't buy the backup/archive distinction as defined. It's totally coherent to 
say "I want a backup of data set xyz", where that isn't exactly one file 
system. I have backups of the data I care about, and I've judged that, for my 
usage, the moderate inconvenience and tiny risk of not having full FS backups 
is worth the trade off.

(note I don't dispute that backup/archive is an important distinction, I just 
think that draws the line in the wrong place.)

Reply via email to