> if you mount onto one, you'll see the mounted files > on the other. > > gorka was talking about identifying files from their qid. > the version number doesn't help in identifying the file - > someone could have modified the file 35 times between > stats.
what definition of "file" are you using? you've rejected the definition that "file" is identified uniquely by path. you've also rejected the definition that file is identified uniquely by qid. > anyway, even if the version number is the same, the contents > may be different. i claim that a fs with this behavior would be broken. intro(5) seems to agree with this claim, unless i'm misreading. - erik
